Q & A March 30, 2003

Q & A 1


  1. A 67-year-old gets married with a citizen, who receives social security but doesn’t pay tax. It is the citizen’s son who pays taxes will sponsor him. Will that affect the application of the Green Card?
  2. If a person applies for asylum before getting married with a citizen, will it affect the Green Card application?
  3. Does the married couple need to provide individual phone bills and gas/electricity bills?
  4. If the I-130 and I-485 forms have been submitted to INS, when will the Green Card, Work Permit, and Social Security Card be returned to me? Does INS send the cards to the home address, or do we go to INS to retrieve them?
    5. Is it Okay to move to other states while waiting for the permanent resident status? If yes, what kinds of procedures do we have to go through with INS? Doe the time waited in New York is waived?

Dear reader:

  1. It is always best for the petitioning U.S. citizen to support the spouse. Under the law, the petitioner is allowed to have a joint sponsor if the petitioner is unable to meet the financial sponsorship obligations by himself/herself. The petitioner of course must still submit an I-864 affidavit of support even if not able to meet the obligation of sponsorship. In such situation, an INS officer might certainly look twice at the case asking the question of why an individual would marry with another if he/she could hardly support himself or herself.
  2. If the alien spouse in this case requested political asylum before marrying with the U.S. citizen, such request even under the best of conditions, e.g. no issuance of asylum denials, referrals to court, inconsistencies in the application vis-a-vis the present marriage, would possibly complicate the application based upon marriage. We have seen many situations in which such cases cannot be closed out for many months after a favorable adjustment interview because the INS officer did not have the complete file of the alien at the time of the interview and must wait for the files to be received and reviewed prior to the officer making a final decision. If the asylum case did not go well, further complications could ensue including inability to adjust status to permanent residence.
  3. In an immigration case based upon marriage, the INS looks for evidence of the bonafide nature of the relationship. Some individuals believe that the only thing that is required for a valid marriage is that the marriage certificate is real and not fake. That is very far from the truth as the INS generally assumes that the certificate is real, but looks to see whether the qualifying relationship is real -- whether the couple are sharing a life together in the same house, same bedroom, same bed. All papers tending to show a shared life are relevant to the INS including telephone bills and utility bills.
  4. Where an adjustment of status application has been submitted to the INS with a request for employment authorization, the speed of INS adjudication depends upon the speed of local office of the INS. The different offices of INS across the nation have differing backlogs of cases and so a case which could be adjudicated to conclusion within six months in one state could take upwards to two years in another district office. From your fifth question (below), you appear to be from New York. Presently it is taking the Manhattan office of INS approximately 18 months + to interview an individual for permanent residence through marriage. Employment authorization can be given in approximately five months. The INS has nothing to do with social security cards. That is the function of the Social Security Administration. With reference to the employment authorization cards, New York INS will send a notice to you to appear in its office to have a picture taken and to give you the card. With that card, you can go to any social security office to apply for a Social Security card. With reference to the green card, you and your husband will both be interviewed to determine the bonafide nature of your relationship and whether you are eligible to adjust status in the United States. If your interview is favorable and all necessary clearances have been made by the government, the INS officer will generally stamp temporary proof of residence status into your passport. With such stamp, you are allowed to leave the United States and work legally for a one-year period of time. Within that one year, the actual card should be mailed to you from the service center of the INS having jurisdiction over your residence.
  5. If you and your husband leave the state during the pendency of your application for permanent residence, you should ask both the New York immigration office and the INS office which would then have jurisdiction over you to have your case transferred from New York to that office. I do note that transferring a case from New York INS can be a challenging and time consuming process. We have had cases which were transferred in a short period, but at the same time have had cases that took six months + to be received by the other INS office. When the receiving office finally has the file, the timing of your interview will depend upon the handling procedure of that office.

 

Copyright © 2003 Alan Lee, Esq.
The information provided here is of a general nature and may not apply to any particular set of facts or circumstances. It should not be construed as legal advice and does not constitute an engagement of the Law Office of Alan Lee or establish an attorney-client relationship.