Q & A November 9, 2003

Q & A 1 2


Dear Mr. Alan Lee

I am an American citizen. In January of ’93, I filed a petition for my sister to immigrate to the United States from China. The petition was approved and the priority date was set at March of ’93. My sister’s child was 15 years old at the time when the petition was approved. But now her child has aged out because she has turned 22.

Question:

Under the CSPA, if my sister immigrates to the United States in 2005 with her child, who will be 24 at that time, will the child be able to come with her?

Pan

Dear reader:

At this time, the BCIS (Bureau of Citizenship and Immigration Services) has not set forth final regulations for the CSPA. As you are aware, my complaint against the various guidances provided so far by BCIS are that the interpretations are restrictive and incomplete (not addressing a variety of situations at this time). I believe that a more reasonable interpretation of the CSPA (Child Status Protection Act) would allow a derivative beneficiary like your sister's child to assume your sister's priority date and immigrate with his sister's priority date under the "appropriate category", as provided by statute. Under current BCIS/DOS (Department of State) interpretations, your sister's child would not be able to immigrate as the petition was approved much before August 6, 2002, the enactment date of the CSPA, and the child aged out prior to the date of enactment. (I assume from your question that the petition took only two months to approve in 1993). BCIS/DOS have stated that where the petition is approved before August 6, 2002, the applicant is not eligible for benefits under the CSPA unless no "final determination" on an adjustment of status or immigrant visa application had been made by that date. DOS has further stated that it would consider that a final determination is made automatically on the ageout date of the child.


Dear Mr. Alan Lee

My Green Card currently is conditional, and it’s due in June. I’ll be able to apply for a permanent one afterwards. Before marrying to a U.S. citizen, I had petitioned for political asylum. My daughter, who was born in 1988, came to the U.S. as an asylee dependent. Her custody belongs to my ex-husband, who is in China. It will be a long time for her to obtain the Green Card if either she files for herself as an asylee dependent, or I, a Green Card holder, petition for her.

Questions:
1. What should we do in order for her to obtain the status?
2. As the stepfather, my husband can petition for her, but we don’t have the custody. Is it possible to do so?

Zhao

Dear reader:

  1. If your husband is willing to sponsor your daughter for permanent residence, he can do so as she is considered his child for immigration purposes since your marriage was celebrated prior to your child turning the age of 18.
  2. It is certainly possible for your husband to petition for your child. However, at the adjustment of status interview, you may be asked to provide evidence that your ex-husband has consented to her staying in the United States with you under permanent residence status. If he does not consent, you can either wait until your daughter reaches the age of consent or you attempt to obtain a modification of custody.

 

Copyright © 2003 Alan Lee, Esq.
The information provided here is of a general nature and may not apply to any particular set of facts or circumstances. It should not be construed as legal advice and does not constitute an engagement of the Law Office of Alan Lee or establish an attorney-client relationship.